Elvis Presley – “From Elvis in Memphis: Legacy Edition” (2009)

Recent review from the PopMatters website, by Christel Loar (Aug. 13, 2009), of the new remastered and deluxe edition version of Elvis’ greatest album — From Elvis in Memphis (1969), that came out months after his triumphant 1968 comeback TV special.
This is posted in honor of the 32nd anniversary of the King’s passing. Gone, but never forgotten…
Hot on the heels of the phenomenal success of his so called “‘68 Comeback Special,” aired that December on NBC, Elvis Presley made one of the smartest moves of his career. He returned to Memphis, for the first time since his days with Sun Records, to record an album.
From Elvis in Memphis: Legacy Edition is the result of those 1969 recordings, and 40 years later, it’s easy to see why so many fans and critics consider this the pinnacle of the King’s powers as an artist. It’s Elvis at his best, and fully aware of that fact. He’s surrounded by top-notch writers and musicians and, as with the television performance, he’s clearly having fun doing something he loves. He’s in the best vocal shape since before his stint in the army, and he’s quite possibly more open to various styles and sounds than when he did his first Sun sessions.
Disc one of the Legacy Edition follows the 12 original From Elvis in Memphis tracks with four bonus recordings from the sessions, including a cover of “Hey Jude” that, although Presley plays fast and loose with the lyrics—or possibly, just doesn’t know them very well, given his laughter at the end of the song—is yet another surprising example, among many on this album, of both the power of his voice and his willingness to pull from all sorts of musical sources.
Disc two adds the ten tracks, also from the 1969 Memphis sessions, initially featured on the first half of From Memphis to Vegas – From Vegas to Memphis, which has seen some of its songs reissued over the years as Back in Memphis, and as parts of various compilations. These, along with four single mixes of album tracks and six non-album singles, round out the Legacy Edition release for a total of 36 tracks from Elvis’s sessions at Chip Moman’s American Studio. The singles appear in their original mono format and include both the chart hits, like “In the Ghetto,” “Suspicious Minds,” “Kentucky Rain,” and “Don’t Cry Daddy,” as well as their B-sides, such as “Any Day Now,” “You’ll Think of Me,” “My Little Friend,” and “Rubberneckin’.”
Extensive liner notes for this set were written by the Memphis based authors, filmmakers, and historians Robert Gordon and Tara McAdams, whose works include the books “It Came From Memphis” and “The Elvis Handbook” and the documentary filmsRespect Yourself: The Stax Records Story and Shakespeare Was a Big George Jones Fan: Cowboy Jack Clement’s Home Movies. In addition to those notes, the accompanying booklet features several wonderful photos of Elvis with his Memphis band and back up singers and of his opening night in Las Vegas. A complete list of musicians at the sessions and details of the overdubs is also included.
Of course, it’s still the music that really sets this set apart. The newly remastered recordings allow listeners to experience every nuance of Elvis’s phrasing and delivery, and it’s truly difficult to choose specific tracks that stand out among such singular performances. On the first disc, “Any Day Now” and “In the Ghetto” are naturally the clinchers, but “Power of My Love” is a stunningly, well, powerful mid-album dark horse. On the second disc, one might argue that it’s all about the singles, but that would do grave injustice to Elvis’s masterful interpretation of Percy Mayfield’s “Stranger in My Own Home Town,” which is a true testament to his unique ability to pay tribute to the artists he loved while simultaneously making a song incontestably his own.
With the fortieth anniversary of the recordings—and the remastering, repackaging, and releasing as a complete collection—From Elvis in Memphis: Legacy Edition has, at long last, given these tracks the treatment they deserve as some of the best music Elvis Presley ever made.
Christel Loar
Elvis Presley – “From Elvis in Memphis” (1969)

If Elvis’ 1968 Comeback Special was the sound of a king, lean and hungry, reclaiming his throne, then this album, released on June 17, 1969, is the sound of Elvis solidifying his powers and proving that the TV special was, indeed, no fluke.
Elvis returned to Memphis on January 13th of that year to record for the first time since he left Sun Records back in 1956. After many years of terrible movies that brought diminishing box office returns and vapid songs that Elvis hated singing, he was clearly ready for a change. His career was on a severe decline, artistically and commercially. He had flailed through the past several years with no direction and little enthusiasm. With the TV special, though, there was hope. He had some momentum and he wasn’t about to concede an inch. He knew this was his last chance to get his career back on track, and start producing music of substance and quality again – to prove that he was no washed-up relic from the distant past. After recording “If I Can Dream” for the special, the year before, he noted, “I’m never going to sing another song I don’t believe in.”
And so set the stage for this album. He went to American Studios, run by producer and songwriter Chips Moman, where dozens of hits were being recorded at the time by this young hotshot. Moman was skeptical, though, as to whether Elvis could still turn out anything of worth, as were the house session musicians. Moman was in awe of Elvis, but he was not about to let that interfere with his judgement. He meant business, and expected the same from Elvis. Everyone’s fears subsided in an instant. Elvis arrived, ready to work. He proved himself right away with a brilliant recording of the song “Long Black Limousine,” whose subject deals with a girl returning to her hometown, after seeking fame and fortune – only the vehicle she’s returning in is a hearse. The poignant subject matter was certainly something that reflected Elvis’ situation. Was he back in Memphis to reclaim former glories or to be buried? Judging from his impassioned reading of this old country song, the answer is clear: this was to be no funeral. As he states in the first line of album opener “Wearin’ That Loved On Look,” “I had to leave town for a little while.” Well, he’s definitely back. Sometimes, you really can go back home again.
From there, it just got better. Elvis recorded one soon-to-be classic after another. There were so many, in fact, that some were held over for future albums. Others, like the brilliant “Suspicious Minds” or “Kentucky Rain,” were released as singles only – returning him to his hitmaking glories. One of the most underrated recordings of his career came with a marvelous reading of the then-current Jerry Butler R&B hit, “Only the Strong Survive.” Elvis’ version more than holds its own, as he turns this song into an autobiographical anthem – his statement of purpose. With the inspired background vocals, excellent playing by the musicians and the slightly speeded-up chorus, perfection was achieved. Elvis never sang better. Elsewhere, he recorded great versions of country tunes like Hank Snow’s “I’m Movin’ On” and Eddy Arnold’s “I’ll Hold You in My Heart (Till I Can Hold You in My Hands)” (complete with false starts). On the bluesy “Power of My Love,” Elvis sounds hungrier than he’s ever sounded in his life. The man is ferocious and ready to take prisoners.
Elvis showed with this album, that, as always, he could handle any type of material – rock & roll, country, R&B, ballads, blues – you name it. His soulful reading of the Burt Bacharach ballad “Any Day Now” (a hit for Chuck Jackson in 1962), is another highlight. Again, Elvis proved, once and for all, what a truly breathtaking singer he could be when given the right material. “True Love Travels on a Gravel Road” is also given a beautiful reading, with excellent backing by the musicians. Elvis proved during these sessions that he had developed a newfound maturity as a singer. As great as he was in his earlier days, he could have never pulled off these kinds of performances during that time.
The album closes with his classic recording of the Mac Davis topical song “In the Ghetto,” which became a big hit for Elvis. This poignant song, which he sings with understated subtlety and heartbreaking pathos, never fails to move. In a few short, simple lines, this song, and Elvis’ reading of it, conveys the tragedy of the unending cycle of poverty. The song can bring you close to tears. And so the album ends on a sad, but emotional high. Elvis clearly wanted people to walk away with something on their minds beside merely feeling entertained.
From Elvis in Memphis made it to #13 on the Billboard charts when it was released. It set up his triumphant return to live performing and proved his comeback special was only a warmup. His resurgence and commercial fortunes would continue for a few more years before the concerts started to become as much of a grind as the movies had been. Elvis grew bored, his marriage collapsed, his health declined, his pill-taking increased, and it all ended in unspeakable tragedy, as we all know. The momentum couldn’t be sustained indefinitely. None of that takes away one single thing, though, from what he accomplished in a small Memphis studio in the early part of 1969. As the liner notes to the new expanded edition of this album state, “A comeback is, damn it, still a comeback.” And with this collection of songs, Elvis certainly proved one thing – he was back, better than ever.
Jay Mucci
Bono – “Elvis: American David” (1995)
elvis son of tupelo.
elvis mama’s boy.
elvis the twin brother of Jesse who died at birth and was buried in a shoe box.
elvis drove a truck.
elvis was recorded at sun studios by the musical diviner sam phillips.
elvis was managed by colonel tom parker, an ex-carnie barker whose last act was a singing canary.
elvis was the most famous singer in the world since king david.
elvis lived on his own street.
elvis liked to play speed cop.
elvis had a monkey named scatter before anyone.
elvis wore a cape at the white house when he was presenting nixon with two silver pistols.
elvis was a member of the drug squad.
elvis wore eye make up, just hangin’ out.
elvis wore a gold nudie suit and trained his lip to curl.
elvis was macho, but could sing like a girl.
elvis was not a big talker.
elvis was articulate in every other way.
elvis dyed his hair black to look like valentino.
elvis held a microphone the way valentino held nitanaldi in blood and sand.
elvis dressed black long before he dressed in black.
elvis sang black except in lower registers where he was a student of dean martin.
elvis admired mario lanza.
elvis delivered the world from crooning.
elvis was a great crooner.
elvis had a voice that could explain the sexuality of america.
elvis was influenced by jim morrison in his choice of black leather for the ‘68 comeback special.
elvis invented the beatles.
elvis achieved world domination from a small town.
elvis was conscious of myth.
elvis had pharoah-like potential.
elvis was made by america, so america could remake itself.
elvis had good manners.
elvis was a bass, a baritone, and a tenor.
elvis sang his heart out at the end.
elvis the opera singer.
elvis the soap opera.
elvis loved america, God, the bible, firearms, the movies, the office of presidency, junk food, drugs, cars, family,television, jewellery, straight talkin’, dirty talkin’ gameshows, uniforms, and self-help books.
elvis like america, wanted to improve himself.
elvis like america, started out loving but later turned on himself.
elvis body could not stop moving.
elvis is alive, we’re dead.
elvis the charismatic.
elvis the ecstatic.
elvis the plastic, elvis the elastic with a spastic dance that might explain the energy of america.
elvis fusion and confusion.
elvis earth rod in a southern dorm.
elvis shaking up an electrical storm.
elvis in hollywood his voice gone to ground.
elvis in las vegas with a big brassy sound.
elvis the first rock’n'roll star with scotty moore, bill black, and dj fontana.
elvis with james burton and ronnie tutt.
elvis the movie star made three good films: viva las vegas, flaming star, and jailhouse rock.
elvis the hillbilly brought rhythm to the white race, blues to pop, and rock’n'roll to where ever rock’n'roll is.
elvis the pelvis, swung from africa to europe, which is the idea of america.
elvis liberation.
elvis the kung fu would come later.
elvis hibernation.
elvis built a theme park he later called Graceland.
elvis woke up to whispers.
elvis thought of himself as a backslider.
elvis knew guilt like a twin brother.
elvis called God every morning then left the phone off the hook.
elvis turned las vegas into a church when he sang “love me tender”.
elvis turned america into a church when he sang “the trilogy”.
elvis was harangued by choice; flesh vs spirit, God vs rock’n'roll mother vs lover, father vs the colonel.
elvis grew sideburns as a protest against tom jones’ hairy chest.
elvis would have a president named after him.
elvis was one of the boys.
elvis was not one of the boys.
elvis had an acute intelligence disguised as talent.
elvis broke priscilla’s heart.
elvis broke lisa marie’s heart.
elvis woke up my heart.
elvis white trash.
elvis the memphis flash.
elvis didn’t smoke hash and woulda been a sissy without johnny cash.
elvis didn’t dodge the draft.
elvis had his own aircraft.
elvis having a laugh on the lisa marie in a colour photograph.
elvis under the hood.
elvis cadillac blood.
elvis darling bud flowered and returned to the mississippi mud.
elvis ain’t gonna rot.
elvis in a memphis plot.
elvis didn’t hear the shot but the king died just across the lot from.
elvis vanilla ice cream.
elvis girls of 14.
elvis memphis spleen shooting at the tv reading corinthians 13.
elvis with God on his knees.
elvis on three tvs.
elvis here come the killer bees head full of honey, potato chips and cheese.
elvis the bumper stickers.
elvis the white knickers.
elvis the white nigger ate at burger king and just kept getting bigger.
elvis sang to win.
elvis the battle to be slim.
elvis ate america before america ate him.
elvis stamps, elvis necromance.
elvis fans, elvis sychophants.
elvis the public enemy.
elvis don’t mean shit to chuck d.
elvis changed the centre of gravity.
elvis made it slippy.
elvis hitler, elvis nixon, elvis christ, elvis mishima.
elvis marcus, elvis jackson, elvis the pelvis.
elvis the psalmist, elvis the genius, elvis the generous.
elvis forgive us.
elvis pray for us
elvis aaron presley (1935-1977)
Bono
Stephen Rudko – “Reinventing Elvis: The American Sound Studio Sessions”
An article on Elvis from the webzine Perfect Sound Forever. There is no exact date on this, but appears to be from 2007-08…
It was bitter cold the evening of January 13, 1969, in Memphis, Tennessee. Producer Chips Moman and the searing band of musicians he had assembled at American Sound Studios were waiting the arrival of Elvis Presley and his notorious retinue. It would be the first evening of a scheduled ten day recording venture. It would also be the first such session for Presley outside of Nashville or Hollywood since he cut his last side for Sam Phillips at Sun Studio in 1955.
The next few weeks were to be a milestone in Presley’s career. On his own initiative, with considerable encouragement and prodding from his friends, he would slip from under his agent’s conservative and protective control to work with one of the hottest house bands and one of the hottest producers in the country. He would break many well-worn habits that had put his career in neutral. He would make a sustained effort to recreate himself and re-establish his musical dominance. And he would assemble strong new material for an adventurous live act set to open July 31st, later that year in Las Vegas.
That Presley would rise to and seize the occasion now seems, viewed through the layers of legend shrouding every aspect of his life, a done deal. Elvis had only to show up at American Sound and spin wax into gold. But on that cold evening, at 827 Thomas Street, in a dilapidated, black section of his adopted hometown, the jury was still out.
Elvis’s decision to leave Hollywood and return to the live stage had been slow in coming. For ten long years, he had dedicated his career to filming B-quality musicals at the grueling schedule of three or so a year. The profits were certain. Elvis would never lose money at the box office. But the receipts began to dwindle as the years went by and the quality of the material he accepted through his agent, Colonel Tom Parker, remained consistently mediocre. For Elvis, motivation was never about money. Presley had become bored and restless. And he was embarrassed.
There had been a few early films that had challenged him, even inspired him: Jailhouse Rock, Loving You, King Creole. But after his discharge from the army in 1960, he became trapped in a revolving door of lightweight vehicles, usually set in exotic locals with one excuse after another to strap him in cars, helicopters or boats. Some were notably better than others, but none tended to stretch or risk the leading man. The plots were as formulaic as the music. Take for example, “Song of the Shrimp” from Girls, Girls, Girls (1962), or “El Torro” and “There’s No Room to Rhumba in a Sports Car” from Fun in Acapulco (1963), or “Yoga Is as Yoga Does” from Easy Come, Easy Go (1967).
Presley resented that the financial success of his films, as silly and trivial as they were, enabled the studio to realize more ambitious and risky projects. Rumor had it, and so Elvis believed, that Hal Wallis’s Beckett, with Peter O’Toole and Richard Burton, was financed largely on the windfall from Blue Hawaii. Elvis was paying for the Oscar triumphs of others.
But Presley’s real problem was not the poor quality of his films (the sets for Harum Scarum, 1965, were cardboard leftovers from Cecil B. De Mille’s Anthony and Cleopatra) or the formulaic plots (he called them travelogues) or the grind of the work itself (it had started out as fun with lots of horseplay and, of course, lots of girls, but even that had become routine) or that he would never be taken seriously as an actor (he would be offered a meaty part in Streisand’s remake of A Star is Born, but would slink away from the challenge). The real rub was that making movies “24/7″ had taken Elvis away from his life’s blood: the fans.
And that had left him behind the times. When Martin Luther King was shot and killed just miles away from Graceland on April 4, 1968, and riots erupted across the country, Elvis was singing to Dominick, a bull in Stay Away Joe, his 26th film. The evolution in recording technique and the intensely provocative sounds of the turbulent decade never reached one of his soundtracks. Presley, the revolutionary, the leader of his generation had fallen completely out of touch with an audience he could neither recognize nor trust. He was in serious danger of becoming irrelevant.
The first steps toward recovery came in early 1968. He refused to renew movie contracts and opted to appear in a December television special sponsored by Singer. Part of the special would be taped in front of a live audience, the so-called “pit” segment, in which he appeared in black leather with musicians from his early years: D. J. Fontana, Scotty Moore, Charlie Hodge, and Alan Fortas from the Memphis Mafia. For the first time in seven years, Presley performed live. And when all was said and done, after all the worry and uncertainty, Elvis proved definitively, not just to his stalwart fans, who would be there to the bitter end anyway, but to himself that he still had that intangible “it.”
Many of the songs were nostalgic, “Blue Suede Shoes,” “Hound Dog,” “Mystery Train,” etc. The fans always wanted to be reminded of the good old days. But there were some refreshing new sounds, “Memories” by Billy Strange and Mac Davis, and “Guitar Man” by Jerry Reed, which Elvis had recorded the previous year.
Most importantly, there was the gospel-bluesy “If I Can Dream,” written especially for the close by musical director, W. Earl Brown. Elvis resisted Colonel Parker’s standing order that the special close with a standard Christmas carol and avoid any kind of social comment. Steve Binder, the producer, felt a message song about peace, humanity and brotherhood would be a bold and fitting send off. Binder sold the idea to Elvis:
Earl sat down at the piano and played it through. Elvis sort of sat there listening. He didn’t comment; he just said, “Play it again.” So Earl sat there and played it again – and again. Then Elvis started to ask some questions about it, and I would venture to say Earl probably played the song six or seven times in a row. Then Elvis looked at me and said, “We’re doing it.”
It was a significant and unusual moment. Elvis rarely over-ruled Parker, and it demonstrates the confidence he felt as he began to retool his image.
The Singer Special was an enormous success and insured a lucrative contract in Las Vegas for the coming summer. An eager audience waited for him, and as generous and as forgiving as his fans had always been, he would have to meet great expectations. Elvis needed something new to communicate, music to address a mature and intelligent audience. He needed records. He needed hit records.
The day after his 34th birthday on January 9, 1969, Elvis met with RCA producer, Felton Jarvis, in the Jungleroom at Graceland to discuss going to Nashville to record what he hoped would put him back on top of the charts.
Jarvis (1936-81) was the off-beat type of guy that appealed to Elvis – he kept a boa constrictor in a burlap bag in his office. Before coming on board with RCA he had produced Fats Domino and Gladys Knight. He also made the hit Shiela for Tommy Roe.
Jarvis got his job after Elvis summarily dismissed an indifferent Chet Atkins in 1966. The incident reveals Presley’s attitude at work.
One night at a session in RCA’s Studio B [in Nashville], Elvis looked over and Chet Atkins was at the console with his head down, asleep. Elvis watched him through the whole damn take, and he never woke up. Elvis waited ’til the session was over, and then he told either Colonel Parker or Tom Diskin [Parker's assistant, ever present at recording sessions], “I don’t want that son of a bitch here anymore.”
Felton had a respectful, hands-off approach. He basically let Elvis run the show. He even allowed him to record gospels songs at their first session, sharing a sensitivity to Presley’s interests that the singer never forgot (these tracks would become the basis for Presley’s second Grammy award winning gospel album How Great Thou Art). Felton’s primary job was to coordinate recording sessions with Colonel Parker’s office. He never picked songs for Elvis or had any say in choosing musicians. Remarkably, the final say on the band came from the Colonel, sometimes through Tom Diskin.
Jarvis seemed to energize Elvis, often imitating his moves while he sang. Elvis genuinely liked him, and they shared a mutual respect and admiration. In 1970, Elvis pulled strings to find Jarvis a kidney for a much needed transplant and then paid for the operation. Later, Presley insisted that Felton accompany him on his tours, hardly a necessity, and when RCA complained that Jarvis was neglecting the other artists for whom he worked, Elvis simply hired him away to be his personal producer. He wanted Jarvis, like so many others, to be at his beck and call. Around 1976, the weary entertainer in a moment of eerie candor confided to the astonished producer, “I’m just so tired of being Elvis Presley.”
Freddy Bienstock, manager of Hill and Range Music Publishers, brought the songs to the RCA sessions. H & R owned the subsidiary companies Elvis Presley Music and Gladys Music. Under the publishing arrangement, Elvis and the Colonel and H & R received a percentage of the songwriters’ royalties when Elvis sold their songs. A kind of double dip that could really add up fast. Bienstock would report the recording arrangements personally to Parker so that Presley could be intimately managed from afar.
There was a problem inherent in the Hill and Range set up that had been and always would be a thorn in the side of success. Initially, when Elvis was the hottest act on the planet, songwriters would willingly cough up profits to have him record (and quite possibly score a hit) with one of their songs. As the industry changed and more artists hit the charts selling millions, and as Elvis’s sales continued to decline, writers became increasingly reluctant to share royalties. With Parker and H & R insisting on a slice of the pie, the quality of the material presented for Elvis’s consideration began to suffer seriously. For the ‘69 sessions to succeed, there would have to be a way around petty, third party interests.
The traditional RCA recording method had been long proscribed. Elvis, just as he had at Sun, stood in the middle of the room with a live band around him, often with his harmony group. There was very little over-dubbing. Nashville wasn’t equipped. Elvis preferred it that way, playing off the musicians spontaneously and performing physically. But the style limited the producer’s ability to create and fine tune, and in the end the product could suffer.
With the success of the Singer Special, everyone expected to see Elvis on top of his game. But Presley was known to ape the demos he chose. If he found the material uninspiring, he would simply go through the motions. The sessions could also degenerate into mayhem depending on Presley’s mood, which could be fickle and which his entourage was always quick to pick up on. It was more or less their job to make sure he was happy and that meant tending to and encouraging his slightest whim. One especially important member of that often maligned crew was Marty Lacker.
Lacker first met Elvis at Humes High when they were both in school. In 1960, Elvis invited him out to Hollywood for the Kid Galahad shoot, and Marty stayed on, a made man in the Memphis Mafia. In 1964, Lacker became foreman of the group, Presley’s personal secretary and check writer. He lived for a time at Graceland in a garage apartment with wife and daughter and served as co-best man with Joe Esposito at Elvis’s Vegas wedding in ‘67.
In 1966, Lacker took a promising position to start a new company called Pepper Records and that had him moving and shaking in the Memphis music scene. Before long he was doing production work with Chips over at American Sound Studios, where Red West, Elvis’s childhood friend, was doing session work. Lacker was very impressed: “They were all white guys, but to hear them play you’d swear they were black.”
Chips Moman founded American Sound Studios in 1965, after finding himself devoid of any real controlling interest in the Stax studio he had helped to create. He was determined to never be cheated again. Around him he gathered a dedicated band of immense quality: Bobby Wood, John Hughey, Tommy Cogbill, Mike Leech, Reggie Young, Gene Chrisman, Ed Kollis, and Bobby Emmons. Collectively, they would place 125 records on the charts over a span of five years.
American Studios was literally located in the ghetto. After King’s assassination, Memphis was a tense place to be, especially in the black neighborhoods. So Moman kept dogs around and occasionally put a guard on the roof armed with a shotgun to watch over the parking lot.
Lacker knew American’s sound was right for Elvis. It was more commercial and country than their rival, soul oriented Stax. Chips’ technique was also up to date. He would cut a rough vocal track with the rhythm section, setting the structure and tone of the song. Later he would sweeten or orchestrate, adding horns or strings. The artist would then be called back in to lay down the main vocal tracks.
Whenever Lacker mentioned how great working with Chips would be, Elvis would say, “Well, I’ll think about it,” or “One of these days soon we’ll try it.” And Chips would needle Lacker about when Elvis was going to come in and record. “When are you going to tell Elvis to let me produce a record?” But what could Lacker tell him?
Lacker was sitting there in the Jungleroom that January evening, seething, as he listened to Elvis and Felton finalize the dates for Nashville. He began to unconsciously shake his head back and forth (his head was big, bald and round and as a result his nickname was Moon). He fought back his frustration. Elvis snapped at him, “What the hell’s the matter with you?” and Lacker got the opening he needed to lay it on the line one last time: What about Chips? His band is on fire, turning out hits with big stars – hell, Dusty Springfield came all the way from Britain to work with him just to get that Memphis sound. Why don’t you just try Chips and American?
And [Elvis] said, “Well, maybe someday I will.”
Then everybody got up to go in the dining room, but I just sat there [cursing]. I didn’t want to go sit at the table and hear them talk about the Nashville session…
Well it wasn’t two minutes before Felton came out and said “Elvis wants to see you.”
I said, “Felton, I don’t want to go in there. With all due respect to you and Nashville, I really don’t want to hear about it.” And he said, “No he wants to talk to you about cutting in Memphis.” Well, I was out of that chair in a flash.
Lacker only had four days to set it up. Elvis was on a tight schedule. He still had to shoot one last picture, Change of Habit with Mary Tyler Moore, for MGM, and he had to get busy preparing a live act. Then there was the problem of studio time. Elvis wanted to begin on Monday, but Neil Diamond had been scheduled in that slot. And Elvis worked at night, through the early hours of the morning. How accommodating would Chips be?
Lacker called Chips at his home to let him know that Elvis was willing to give American a go. He let him know the constraints, emphasizing that it had to be a closed session, no guests, no publicity. And he reminded him of the scheduling conflict that would have to be resolved. Diamond was a pretty big star himself. Chip’s exact words were, “Fuck Neil Diamond. Neil Diamond will just have to be postponed. Tell Elvis he’s on.”
Colonel Parker had lost control of his number one asset during an evening dinner at Graceland. His greatest fear was being realized. Elvis had actually made a major decision without seeking either his advice or permission. The question for Parker became how to keep the situation from spinning totally out of his sphere of influence.
Jarvis was too close to Elvis to be counted on to keep a real eye on things. Besides, he had abdicating his position to Chips. He might be able to play a part in post-production, but Chips’ take charge, no bullshit attitude ruled out any serious input in the studio. Parker could only send Diskin and RCA vice-president Harry Jenkins to the sessions to make sure everyone on the gravy train was having his interests considered. Those interests may have been primarily Parker’s, but they were also, the Colonel genuinely felt, Elvis’s. The two, of course, were inseparable.
Oh, and Parker could also send music, lots and lots of music from the Hill and Range catalog. On that count, he thought he was well set up, believing that he had practically placed an insider in Presley’s camp.
Lamar Fike was one of Elvis’s oldest and closest personal friends. At the request of Elvis’s mother, Gladys, he had accompanied Private Presley to Germany, where he served as chauffeur and valet. Throughout the years he would be an integral part of the organization. He survived the wholesale housecleaning in 1976, which resulted in the backlash, tell-all book, Elvis, What Happened? From early on his corpulence and feisty attitude marked him as Elvis’s general whipping post. But Fike was trusted and always played an important role. He introduced Elvis to Jarvis in 1966, in an attempt to lure him away from Hollywood and back to Nashville. After the American sessions, he would run lights for the stage show in Vegas. In the ‘70’s, insulated from Elvis’s often violent mood swings, he would work advance on the countless tours. He would also serve as one of Presley’s pallbearers.
Fike started working at H & R in 1962, at times in close association with Parker and the home office. And though Fike was a champion of H & R, and worked on their behalf and had practically been placed in the job by the Colonel, he was a team player. After all, what was good for H & R was making money for Elvis too.
Fike was selling one song, “Kentucky Rain” by Eddie Rabbitt and Dick Heard, that he had a really good feeling about. Elvis wasn’t too impressed, but Fike was persistent. Elvis had to cut it, it was that good, and if he didn’t somebody else was going to chart with it. It was a smart call and Fike would later feel proud. When “Kentucky Rain” was released in 1970, it stayed nine weeks in the top 100, reaching #16. And according to plan, H & R took 50 percent interest in the song and Elvis’s subsidiary took half of that.
Chips began to prepare for Elvis. He pulled songs from his own library he knew Elvis could sink his teeth into. Some he had cut with other artists, some hadn’t worked out just right. “Suspicious Minds” was one. Chips had recorded it with the song’s writer Mark James in 1968 for Scepter, but the record never made the charts. Chips thought he had a good chance with Elvis whose voice and intensity were perfect for the song. When the time came to cut the tracks, Chip used same arrangement as with James (played by the same band), believing that only Elvis was the missing ingredient to a hit record. He was right. It was the last time Elvis would have a number one record on the Hot 100.
Lacker briefed Chips on how Elvis was used to working, on the right things to say and do. Chips wouldn’t need to tell Presley when he was off key or when he made a mistake. And musically he needn’t meddle. Elvis knew what was right for him, he had been doing this a long time. But Chips ignored Lacker’s unsolicited advice. He wasn’t about to curb his talent just to spare Elvis’s ego. The studio was his to control, the band his to direct, and well, Chips figured that when somebody hired him to do a job they were trusting him to go ahead and do it.
(In a January 2007 e-mail, Lacker disputes this, saying: “I did not tell Chips what to say or not say to Elvis. I did tell him about the security and closed session aspect but that’s all. One of the things I knew and respected about Chips was that he was in control of his sessions and I would never tell him what to say or do.”)
In 1994, Chips remembered:
Hindsight’s 20/20 I guess, but I didn’t really think anything so special about getting the chance to record Elvis – not when it happened. Oh, it was okay, but to tell you the truth, we were so busy producing records in Memphis back then (and a lot of ‘em were hits ‘cause we were hot at the time with Neil Diamond and a lot of other stars) that we had to actually work a double shift and cut Roy Hamilton during the day and Elvis at night in order to do those albums. He only had so much open time on his schedule. Now don’t get me wrong. I had always liked Elvis. I always loved his music, especially the early years of his career, but I just went in to work on it like any other project – no big deal. You see, most everybody in Memphis kind of took Elvis for granted – didn’t pay any attention to how big a star he really was. Remember, he was a hometown boy. He’s bigger now in Memphis than he ever was in his best days when he was alive.
The sessions began as scheduled that Monday evening. To Chips and the band it was business as usual. If anything, they were suspicious of all the hype. They were also proud. Elvis was coming to them, to get their help, their sound. They were used to working with big stars and with big egos and Elvis was known to have one of the biggest. But they were also used to producing good material and Elvis hadn’t been doing that for quite some time. Presley was going to have to prove himself. Even so, when Elvis pulled into the back parking lot, Bobby Wood could just sense he had arrived.
I just felt his presence. I felt him. It was almost like Christ was out there or something. There was no doubt about it. I tell you what, I got chill bumps when he came in. I couldn’t help it. It just happened. You knew he was there.
“What a funky, funky place,” Elvis muttered when he entered, possibly to calm his nerves. He was trailed by his regular bunch of guys: Fike, Lacker, Joe Eposito, Sonny and Red West, WHBQ deejay George Klein, and of course Jarvis. Tom Diskin from Parker’s office was there to keep watch, so was Freddy Bienstock, representing H & R, and RCA’s Harry Jenkins. Three or four of the boys on a well established cue pulled cigarette lighters out when Elvis stuck a thin cigar in his mouth. The band cringed.
Chips thought it an aggravation to have all those people around. It was an aggravation for everybody. Elvis was always playing to the guys, always trying to say something cute, keep them laughing. It could get pretty hectic. But for whatever reason, Elvis needed his friends around. They made him feel comfortable. It may have seemed phony to everyone else, but this was the real world to Elvis Presley.
That first night, after a hesitant beginning (everyone needed to get comfortable with one another and Elvis seemed to have opening night jitters), it became clear, and was a particular relief to the musicians, that Elvis meant business. He responded positively to Chips’ direction, and listened attentively even when Chips interrupted him in mid song, admonishing Elvis to “try it again.” It was the same attentiveness and focus Presley had paid to Binder and the Singer Special.
Chips only recorded three songs that evening, “Long Black Limousine” by Bobby George and Vern Stovall, that Chips introduced, “This Is the Story” by Arnold, Morrow and Martin, from Freddy Beinstock and H & R and “Wearin’ that Loved On Look” by Dallas Frazier and Al Owens, which Lamar had brought in. Even so, the session didn’t break up till four the next morning and everyone seemed satisfied. On the ride back to Graceland, Elvis turned to the guys in the back and told them what seemed obvious. “Man, that felt really great. I can’t tell you how good I feel… I really just want to see if I can have a number one record one more time.”
For the first three days, the sessions went according to plan. Elvis wanted to record some songs that Chips really had no interest in (“Yesterday,” for example), and he would back away until Elvis got them out of his system. Then the cold which had been bothering Presley for weeks came back with a vengence. Elvis stayed at Graceland for a few days to recuperate while Chips cut background and laid down some rhythm tracks for a few new songs.
Chips had a song by Mac Davis that he knew would be a hit, “In the Ghetto” (Lacker disputes this, saying that Elvis “brought that to the session on a tape of Mac Davis’ songs that he got from Billy Strange who at the time was with Nancy Sinatra’s publishing company who had Mac under a writer’s contract”). Elvis liked Davis and his songs, like “A Little Less Conversation,” but he wasn’t sure about this one. It was a message ballad about the cycle of poverty in the ghetto. It was not typical of what Elvis recorded and it went against the Colonel’s no politics rule. In a press conference in 1972, Elvis made this philosophy clear when asked what he thought of war protesters and whether he would refuse to be drafted: “Honey, I’d just soon to keep my own personal views to myself. ‘Cause I’m just an entertainer and I’d rather not say.”
George Klein really didn’t think it was a good song for Elvis and told him so, but Chips was insistent. Elvis said he’d think about it.
Back at Graceland, Elvis and the guys were going through the demos the Colonel had sent from H & R. Elvis was distraught. They were running out of good songs and this batch was just awful. Why wouldn’t they send him some good material for a change? Marty spoke up: the H & R situation was costing Elvis hit songs. Elvis needed to consider music which the Colonel didn’t have a bonus interest in. Presley sat for a while, grinding his teeth and nervously bouncing his leg, language that was an indication that the keg was about to blow.
And finally it did. Business was business, but from now on everybody was going to bring in songs. And if they had the publishing rights, well, OK, but if not, and they were good songs, then the hell with it. He was going to cut them anyway.
Klein, whose radio connections were significant, immediately got on the phone and secured “The Grass Won’t Pay No Mind” from Neil Diamond. Klein also had second thoughts about “In the Ghetto.” He had been thinking about it the day after and his advice had been a mistake. When he told Elvis he thought the song would be a hit, Presley grinned, “No shit, I’m cutting it tonight.”
Back in the studio, Elvis began work on “Suspicious Minds” and “In the Ghetto.” It was obvious that these were going to be big records. Diskin and Bienstock began to get antsy. They caught Chips alone in the hall and started working on him, trying to get a piece of the songs he owned. Finally Chips had had enough.
Gentlemen, I thought we were here to cut some hit records. Now if that’s not the case, let me tell you what you can do. You can take your fucking tapes, and you and your whole group can get the hell out of here. Don’t ask me for something that belongs to me. I’m not going to give it to you.
Surprisingly, RCA’s Jenkins chimed in with Chips. The session was going well. Everybody was going to make out just fine. There was no need to let the whole thing unravel.
Diskin was furious and sought out Elvis to plead his case. But Presley had already made up his mind. He wasn’t going to let the home office or H & R or RCA for that matter, ruin his session. He politely told Diskin to let him and Felton and Chips handle things.
Presley then did something which surprised even Chips. He asked the producer how they could eliminate the hassels, and Chips told him to just get everyone out of there. And that was it.
Diskin grabbed the hotline to the Colonel’s office and, frustrated and perplexed, spelled out the circumstances. Elvis was going his own way. He didn’t want them around. They had absolutely no control.
Colonel Parker bristled. There was nothing he could do except tell Diskin to cut out immediately. That would teach Elvis a lesson: “Come back here right now, and let him fall on his ass.”
Many critics and fans alike have often claimed that if only Elvis had taken more control of his career, had trusted his own instincts, made the movies and recorded the music he really wanted, if he had just gotten rid of the Colonel entirely, his career would have been much better off. It’s hard to argue with the Colonel’s success, but it may be said with certainty that in this instance, without being tied by the Presley machine, Elvis rose to and met every challenge.
Marty Lacker puts it succinctly:
So Elvis fell on his ass, all right. In twelve days, he cut thirty-six sides. Four of them were singles – “In the Ghetto,” “Suspicious Minds,” “Don’t Cry Daddy,” and “Kentucky Rain,” and all but the last were gold, even though Kentucky Rain was a substantial hit. And the two albums that came out of it [From Elvis in Memphis and From Memphis to Vegas/From Vegas to Memphis] went platinum. That’s some falling on your ass.
When Elvis walked into American Sound Studio that January evening, he hadn’t had a top five record since 1965. He would never get as high on the charts again as he did with Chips Moman. Elvis himself believed that he had recorded some of his best material. He did so with focus and effort, and by asserting a kind of independence which was unusual for him. But it was an independence tempered by a willingness to work with and be guided by a producer he had never met, in a studio he knew by name only. Desperate for a number one record, Elvis took chances he would never take again.
In 1973, when recording at Stax (also in Memphis), bad habits and boredom returned. During a Monday night session, he had the guys buy a television so he could watch the football game (the TV was left behind when he left). Larry Nix, the engineer, remembers the cookie cutter mentality.
They’d bring a song in… Elvis would listen, and he’d go do it. The song would be done identical to the demo. That dumbfounded me. There was no imagination, no “Create a little bit here,” you know! Felton Jarvis was the producer, but all the production was already done on the demos. They just copied them.
Elvis never returned to American partly because of the divisions it created in his organization and the hassles with his management. But also because he didn’t need to or want to take any more chances. The success of the records and the ensuing act in Vegas spurred him into a flurry of tours and live performances, the whirlwind of which echoed the relentless manufacture of films in the ‘60’s. He would rise to meet the challenge of the Satellite Special from Hawaii, Aloha, but this was almost entirely based on his standard, well-worn repertoire.
By 1974, Elvis didn’t even want to record. He went the year without producing a single side. At the RCA session in March of 1975, Elvis managed ten songs in just three days. Quickly trying to meet his obligations before yet another Vegas opening, the songs were chosen without any sense of direction and did nothing to boost his flagging sales. In 1976, he decided he might just as well record at Graceland, and RCA built a studio of sorts in the Jungleroom. But after six uninspired days and only a handful of songs that showed any real promise, he refused to come out of his bedroom, and RCA packed up and went home. The next year he showed up a day late for a session in Nashville. Elvis was so disconcerted by his girlfriend’s ongoing rejection that he wouldn’t even leave his hotel room. He left for Graceland the next day. In 1977, he all but collapsed while filming a television special for CBS.
But the American sessions stand as a personal triumph for Elvis, a performer at a turning point, an artist who that Winter in Memphis, was again sharp, eager, and alive. And the music he created there will always prove it.
Bibliography
1) Clayton, Rose and Dick Heard, eds. Elvis Up Close. Atlanta, Georgia: Turner Publishing, Inc., 1994.
2) Dickerson, James. Goin’Back to Memphis. New York: Schirmer Books, 1996.
3) Gordon, Robert. It Came from Memphis. Boston: Faber and Faber, 1994.
4) Gray, Michael and Roger Osborne. Elvis Atlas, A Journey through Elvis Presley’s America. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1996
5) Guralnick, Peter. Careless Love, The Unmaking of Elvis Presley. New York: Little, Brown and Company, 1999.
6) Guralnick, Peter. Last Train to Memphis, The Rise of Elvis Presley. New York: Little, Brown and Company, 1994
7) Lacker, Marty, et al. Elvis, Portrait of a Friend. Memphis, Tennessee: Wimmer Brothers Books, 1979.
8.) Nash, Alana, et al. Elvis Aaron Presley, Revelations from the Memphis Mafia. New York: HarperCollins, 1995.
9) Osborne, Jerry. Elvis, Word for Word. New York: Harmony Books, 1999.
10) Pierce, Patricia Jobe. The Ultimate Elvis, Elvis Presley, Day by Day. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1994.
11) Worth, Fred L. and Steve D. Tamerius. Elvis, His Life from A to Z. Chicago, Illinois: Contemporary Books, 1988.
Stephen Rudko
Elvis Presley – “Mystery Train” (1955)
One of Elvis’ early rockabilly classics on Sun Records, produced by the late, great Sam Phillips, who co-wrote it with Junior Parker.
Peter Guralnick – “How Did Elvis Get Turned Into a Racist?” (2007)

Peter Guralnick, who wrote the definitve biography (in 2 parts) of Elvis, wrote this op-ed piece for the New York Times, Aug. 11, 2007. He talks about how Elvis has unfairly been called a racist over the years because of things he was accused of saying (but never actually said) and because of being called “The King of Rock ‘n’ Roll” (a title he never liked) and therefore “ripping off” black music. Elvis never claimed to have “invented” rock ‘n’ roll.
Keep in mind, that even when Elvis uses the term “colored people” (quoted below), that was a perfectly acceptable thing to call African-Americans at that time. Also keep in mind that most of the original black rock ‘n’ rollers (Little Richard, Fats Domino, Chuck Berry) had nothing but the utmost respect for Elvis (and vice versa) and were friends with him, as were B.B. King, Muhammad Ali, Rufus Thomas, Roy Hamilton, Sammy Davis, Jr., etc.
Public opinion is starting to change finally…
One of the songs Elvis Presley liked to perform in the ’70s was Joe South’s “Walk a Mile in My Shoes,” its message clearly spelled out in the title.
Sometimes he would preface it with the 1951 Hank Williams recitation “Men With Broken Hearts,” which may well have been South’s original inspiration. “You’ve never walked in that man’s shoes/Or saw things through his eyes/Or stood and watched with helpless hands/While the heart inside you dies.” For Elvis these two songs were as much about social justice as empathy and understanding: “Help your brother along the road,” the Hank Williams number concluded, “No matter where you start/For the God that made you made them, too/These men with broken hearts.”
In Elvis’s case, this simple lesson was not just a matter of paying lip service to an abstract principle.
It was what he believed, it was what his music had stood for from the start: the breakdown of barriers, both musical and racial. This is not, unfortunately, how it is always perceived 30 years after his death, the anniversary of which is on Thursday. When the singer Mary J. Blige expressed her reservations about performing one of his signature songs, she only gave voice to a view common in the African-American community. “I prayed about it,” she said, “because I know Elvis was a racist.”
And yet, as the legendary Billboard editor Paul Ackerman, a devotee of English Romantic poetry as well as rock ’n’ roll, never tired of pointing out, the music represented not just an amalgam of America’s folk traditions (blues, gospel, country) but a bold restatement of an egalitarian ideal. “In one aspect of America’s cultural life,” Ackerman wrote in 1958, “integration has already taken place.”
It was due to rock ’n’ roll, he emphasized, that groundbreaking artists like Big Joe Turner, Ray Charles, Chuck Berry and Little Richard, who would only recently have been confined to the “race” market, had acquired a broad-based pop following, while the music itself blossomed neither as a regional nor a racial phenomenon but as a joyful new synthesis “rich with Negro and hillbilly lore.”
No one could have embraced Paul Ackerman’s formulation more forcefully (or more fully) than Elvis Presley.
Asked to characterize his singing style when he first presented himself for an audition at the Sun recording studio in Memphis, Elvis said that he sang all kinds of music — “I don’t sound like nobody.” This, as it turned out, was far more than the bravado of an 18-year-old who had never sung in public before. It was in fact as succinct a definition as one might get of the democratic vision that fueled his music, a vision that denied distinctions of race, of class, of category, that embraced every kind of music equally, from the highest up to the lowest down.
It was, of course, in his embrace of black music that Elvis came in for his fiercest criticism. On one day alone, Ackerman wrote, he received calls from two Nashville music executives demanding in the strongest possible terms that Billboard stop listing Elvis’s records on the best-selling country chart because he played black music. He was simply seen as too low class, or perhaps just too no-class, in his refusal to deny recognition to a segment of society that had been rendered invisible by the cultural mainstream.
“Down in Tupelo, Mississippi,” Elvis told a white reporter for The Charlotte Observer in 1956, he used to listen to Arthur Crudup, the blues singer who originated “That’s All Right,” Elvis’s first record. Crudup, he said, used to “bang his box the way I do now, and I said if I ever got to the place where I could feel all old Arthur felt, I’d be a music man like nobody ever saw.”
It was statements like these that caused Elvis to be seen as something of a hero in the black community in those early years. In Memphis the two African-American newspapers, The Memphis World and The Tri-State Defender, hailed him as a “race man” — not just for his music but also for his indifference to the usual social distinctions. In the summer of 1956, The World reported, “the rock ’n’ roll phenomenon cracked Memphis’s segregation laws” by attending the Memphis Fairgrounds amusement park “during what is designated as ‘colored night.’”
That same year, Elvis also attended the otherwise segregated WDIA Goodwill Revue, an annual charity show put on by the radio station that called itself the “Mother Station of the Negroes.” In the aftermath of the event, a number of Negro newspapers printed photographs of Elvis with both Rufus Thomas and B.B. King (“Thanks, man, for all the early lessons you gave me,” were the words The Tri-State Defender reported he said to Mr. King).
When he returned to the revue the following December, a stylish shot of him “talking shop” with Little Junior Parker and Bobby “Blue” Bland appeared in Memphis’s mainstream afternoon paper, The Press-Scimitar, accompanied by a short feature that made Elvis’s feelings abundantly clear. “It was the real thing,” he said, summing up both performance and audience response. “Right from the heart.”
Just how committed he was to a view that insisted not just on musical accomplishment but fundamental humanity can be deduced from his reaction to the earliest appearance of an ugly rumor that has persisted in one form or another to this day. Elvis Presley, it was said increasingly within the African-American community, had declared, either at a personal appearance in Boston or on Edward R. Murrow’s Person to Person television program, “The only thing Negroes can do for me is buy my records and shine my shoes.”
That he had never appeared in Boston or on Murrow’s program did nothing to abate the rumor, and so in June 1957, long after he had stopped talking to the mainstream press, he addressed the issue — and an audience that scarcely figured in his sales demographic — in an interview for the black weekly Jet.
Anyone who knew him, he told reporter Louie Robinson, would immediately recognize that he could never have uttered those words. Amid testimonials from black people who did know him, he described his attendance as a teenager at the church of celebrated black gospel composer, the Rev. W. Herbert Brewster, whose songs had been recorded by Mahalia Jackson and Clara Ward and whose stand on civil rights was well known in the community. (Elvis’s version of “Peace in the Valley,” said Dr. Brewster later, was “one of the best gospel recordings I’ve ever heard.”)
The interview’s underlying point was the same as the underlying point of his music: far from asserting any superiority, he was merely doing his best to find a place in a musical continuum that included breathtaking talents like Ray Charles, Roy Hamilton, the Five Blind Boys of Mississippi and Howlin’ Wolf on the one hand, Hank Williams, Bill Monroe and the Statesmen Quartet on the other. “Let’s face it,” he said of his rhythm and blues influences, “nobody can sing that kind of music like colored people. I can’t sing it like Fats Domino can. I know that.”
And as for prejudice, the article concluded, quoting an unnamed source, “To Elvis people are people, regardless of race, color or creed.”
So why didn’t the rumor die? Why did it continue to find common acceptance up to, and past, the point that Chuck D of Public Enemy could declare in 1990, “Elvis was a hero to most… straight-up racist that sucker was, simple and plain”?
Chuck D has long since repudiated that view for a more nuanced one of cultural history, but the reason for the rumor’s durability, the unassailable logic behind its common acceptance within the black community rests quite simply on the social inequities that have persisted to this day, the fact that we live in a society that is no more perfectly democratic today than it was 50 years ago. As Chuck D perceptively observes, what does it mean, within this context, for Elvis to be hailed as “king,” if Elvis’s enthronement obscures the striving, the aspirations and achievements of so many others who provided him with inspiration?
Elvis would have been the first to agree. When a reporter referred to him as the “king of rock ’n’ roll” at the press conference following his 1969 Las Vegas opening, he rejected the title, as he always did, calling attention to the presence in the room of his friend Fats Domino, “one of my influences from way back.” The larger point, of course, was that no one should be called king; surely the music, the American musical tradition that Elvis so strongly embraced, could stand on its own by now, after crossing all borders of race, class and even nationality.
“The lack of prejudice on the part of Elvis Presley,” said Sam Phillips, the Sun Records founder who discovered him, “had to be one of the biggest things that ever happened. It was almost subversive, sneaking around through the music, but we hit things a little bit, don’t you think?”
Or, as Jake Hess, the incomparable lead singer for the Statesmen Quartet and one of Elvis’s lifelong influences, pointed out: “Elvis was one of those artists, when he sang a song, he just seemed to live every word of it. There’s other people that have a voice that’s maybe as great or greater than Presley’s, but he had that certain something that everybody searches for all during their lifetime.”
To do justice to that gift, to do justice to the spirit of the music, we have to extend ourselves sometimes beyond the narrow confines of our own experience, we have to challenge ourselves to embrace the democratic principle of the music itself, which may in the end be its most precious gift.
Peter Guralnick
Mojo Nixon & Skid Roper – “Elvis is Everywhere” (Video – 1987)
The one & only Mojo Nixon, with his one-time partner Skid Roper doing their unforgettable tribute to The King. Hilarious, insane, spirited and wild – this one had ‘em shakin’ their pelvises back in ‘87.
Note: video quality is not the greatest but what can ya do?
Greil Marcus – “Elvis Presley: Blue Hawaii” (1977)

Greil Marcus’ brilliant epitaph for Elvis – Sept. 22, 1977 – one month after he died. Written for Rolling Stone (Issue #248)…
Tragic News From the Mainland
August 18th Maui, Hawaii
There was a message to call the mainland, so I did. We don’t follow the news much here when we are on vacation; the radio, especially on the outer islands, is mostly static, and this time we had brought along a cassette machine and some homemade tapes and didn’t listen to the radio at all. “They want you to write a piece about Elvis,” I was told on the phone. “An obituary.” What kind of joke is that? I thought. Rolling Stone doesn’t keep a ready file of obits. “What kind of joke is that?” I said. “Why, he died today,” I was told. “A heart attack, apparently.”
I didn’t accept it at all, not in any way, but at the same time I knew it was true, and even as part of me withdrew from that fact, headlines began to fly through my brain: Nude body of George “Superman” Reeves found. Singer drowns in own vomit. James Dean spoke to me from the grave, man claims. I went down to the bar at the hotel where we are staying, and while I was waiting for my wife I ordered a Jack Daniel’s. I would have asked for Wild Turkey, but this was no night to drink Kentucky whiskey; Jack Daniel’s is straight from Tennessee, just like Elvis Presley’s first 45.
Like most other people my age — thirty-two — Elvis mattered to me in the Fifties; I loved his music, bought some of his records, and never went to any of his movies. He was great, but he was also weird, and I kept my distance. Clearly, though, I had some sort of buried fascination for the man, and when he appeared on TV late in 1968 for his comeback, I found I could handle that fascination; in fact, I was caught up in it, and for five years I spent far more time listening to Elvis’ music, from the beginning on down, than to the music of anyone else. I found, or at least decided, that Elvis contained more of America — had swallowed whole more of its contradictions and paradoxes — than any other figure I could think of; I found that he was a great, original American artist; and I found that neither of these propositions were generally understood, at least not in sufficient depth. So of course I wrote about it all, feeling, after 20,000 words, that while I had never written anything so good before, I had only scratched the surface.
I did not write about “a real person”; I wrote about the persona I heard speaking in Elvis’ music. I wrote about the personalization of an idea, of lots of ideas — freedom, limits, risk, authority, sex, repression, youth, age, tradition, novelty, guilt and the escape from guilt — because they all were there to hear; reading my perceptions back onto their source, I understood Elvis not as a human being (his divorce was interesting to me musically) but as a sort of force, as a kind of necessity: that is, the necessity existing in every culture (or anyway ours) that leads it to produce a perfect, all-inclusive metaphor for itself. This, I tried to find a way to say safely, was what Herman Melville attempted to create with the white whale, but this was what Elvis Presley turned out to be. Or rather, made himself into, or maybe, agreed to become. And because such a triumph had to combine absolute determination and self-conscious ambition with utter ease, with the grace of one to whom all good things come naturally, I imagined a special dispensation for Elvis, or, really, read it in the artifacts of his career: that to make all this work, to make this metaphor perfectly, transcendently American, to make it new, it would be free. In other words, this would, as it had to, be a Faustian bargain, but someone else — and who cared who? — would pick up the tab.
I thought about all this, sitting at the bar, still believing every word I had written but wondering: if I had not somehow turned myself into the most lunatic Elvis fan of all. Suddenly I began to get angry. I thought: disgusting, sordid, ugly, sleazy, stupid, wasteful, pathetic. I thought of George Reeves again; for some reason I still could not make the event real — every time I focused on it consciously, the idea of Elvis dead, not here, seemed to imply that he had never been here, that his presence over 23 years had been some kind of hallucination, a trick — and as a way to avoid the recite, I began to glide toward the corpse. I got tough. I played journalist. No one could tell me he died of anything but booze and broads, I said to myself. Isn’t that what everybody in show biz dies from? Why should I think Elvis would be any different? Heart attack, my ass. I dumped the whole affair into Vegas. I wanted to cut loose from it all, but I was still too angry, and confused, not at anyone or anything: not at Elvis, or myself, or “them,” or the fans, or the media, or “rock,” or “success?” It was simply rage. I was devastated.
The following night I watched two separate television specials on Elvis’ death, aired for most of the country the night before but broadcast a day late here in Hawaii. They were strange shows. On ABC one saw Chuck Berry who had never hidden his bitterness at the fact that it took a white man to symbolize the new music Chuck and others, Elvis among them, created; here he did not really try to hide his satisfaction at having lasted longer than “the King.” “For what will Elvis be remembered among other musicians?” Chuck was asked. “Oh,” he replied, “boop boop, boop; shake your leg; fabulous teen music; the Fifties; his movies.” Not a man you’d want to trade ironies with in a dark alley — but even Jerry Lee Lewis, laughing, raving drunk and packing a pistol outside Graceland, demanding to be let in to see the King, had lasted longer. And could television have possibly aired whatever it might have been that Jerry Lee had to say about all this? One saw Elvis performing in Hawaii in 1973 — we had been here at the time, too, and I remember feeling like an idiot as I looked for him on the beach — and in his later incarnation Elvis even began to look like George Reeves.
On NBC’s special, hosted in an even tone by David Brinkley, a panel of experts had been assembled: Murray the K, famous DJ, was the “first civilized person [i.e., Northerner] to play an Elvis record” — The first civilized person [i.e., Northerner] to play an Elvis record — Steve Dunleavy, the as-told-to part of a quartet of authors responsible for a just-published scandal bio called Elvis What Happened? (his co-writers are former Elvis bodyguards, fired over the last year or so), and my friend and colleague Dave Marsh of Rolling Stone. Murray the K looked subdued and played the insider; Elvis, he informed America, had told him, Murray, that he, Elvis, would “not outlive his mother,” who as it happened also died at the age of 42. Uh huh. Dunleavy looked bored, note his Australian accent, and spoke coolly — in the manner of, “Well, you know these showbiz types” — of Elvis in his last few years as a “walking drugstore.” It was a classic case of too much too soon,’” Dunleavy said, trying to slide around the cliché. Dave Marsh, however, is a rock critic; in his case that means not that rock is part of his life because it is his job, but that rock is his job because it is his life. Dave looked shellshocked, scared. He looked the way I was feeling, and he said intelligent things that perhaps not a large percentage of those watching were prepared to understand.
“It’s that Elvis has always been there,” Marsh said. “I always expected him to be a part of American culture that I would share with my children.” And of course that was it. Elvis was not a “phenomenon.” He was not a “craze.” He was not even, or at least not only, a “singer,” or an “artist.” He was that perfect American symbol, fundamentally a mystery, and the idea was that he would outlive us all — or, at least, live for as long as it took both him and us to reach the limits of what that symbol had to say.”
Since I had already read Steve Dunleavy’s book, though, I could not help but think that Elvis’ death might mean that those limits had already been reached, that the symbol had collapsed back upon itself and upon those who had, over the years, paid attention to it. The moment I enjoyed most in Elvis What Happened? came when I read that in 1966 Robert Mitchum offered Elvis the lead in Thunder Road — perfect role for Elvis, and one that would have given him the chance to become the serious actor he had always dreamed of being — and I enjoyed that moment most because I knew that Mitchum had already made Thunder Road, in 1958, and so could conclude that the accuracy of the test of the book might be suspect. Because while many of the events detailed in What Happened? are trivial, of the most unforgettable pillow fight I ever had sort, and some of the most sensationalized (Elvis demanding that his bodyguards set up a hit on the man who took away his wife) clearly inflated, what Red West, Sonny West and Dave Hebler have to say rings mostly true.
The Elvis of What Happened? is a man whose success had, simply, driven him nuts. As presented here-in, of course, the present tense, the authors make much of their desire to save Elvis from himself — Elvis has no sense of the real world whatsoever. He is schizophrenic, a manic depressive, insanely jealous, crazily “generous,” desperate to have loyalty and able to trust no one. Each of these characteristics is seen as inherent in his personality and his unique situation; each is intensified by huge, constant doses of uppers and downers, by an entourage of paid sycophants, by Elvis’ obsession with firearms and by his paranoid fantasies of vengeance and death. Each of these neurotic dislocations seeks some sort of resolution in Elvis’ desire to check the limits of what he can get away with (Can the near death of a young girl who overdosed –according to the book — be covered up? Sure it can.), coupled with his desire to bring punishment upon himself for breaking rules he booms are right. Commentator after commentator on the night of Elvis’ death mentioned that his life was never complete after his mother died, implying that had she lived he would have also; it seems clear, after reading What Happened?, that one route of Elvis’ pathology was his inability — from, inevitably, the beginning — to be as good a boy as his mother must have wanted him to be.
I thought of this, however, only after Elvis’ death; before that, I had not taken the book all that seriously. Now I realize that what I had read in it was at the source of my anger at his death, my sense of ugliness, and waste. The book had disturbed me when I read it, but not that much; I wrote a brief review and forgot about it. It is only now that I can see through the padding and the mean-spiritedness of the volume to what it has to show us: a picture of a man who lived with almost complete access to disaster, all the time. The stories that illustrate this are not all that important; you can read them, or you can make them up, whether they have to do with the onstage freak-out brought on by dope and who knows what else; the M-16 that went off at the wrong time; the rage no one could cool down. There is nothing in this book. I think, that would have ended Elvis’ career had he lived (perhaps today, even the worst possibilities imaginable regarding Elvis’ Army relationship with the then 14-year-old Priscilla might not really bitter him with Middle America; Elvis did finally marry her, after all.) But the book’s last pages, purportedly the transcript of a telephone conversation Elvis had with Red West sometime after Elvis fired him – a conversation in which they discussed the book that had come out as What Happened? — are themselves ending enough.
The feeling I get, reading stuff like this, is that Elvis may well have wanted this book to appear; that he wanted the burden and the glory of acting the King removed once and for all; that he wanted, finally, relief. Of course, that may only be what the authors of What Happened? want us to think. Peter Guralnick has often written about Elvis, and always brilliantly; every time, I think, he has headed his pieces with a quote from William Carlos Williams: “The pure products of America go crazy.” In Elvis’ case both Peter and Williams were obviously right. But it still seems too pat to me, as do the detailed explanations of What Happened?, because to merely reduce something we cannot quite get our heads around to something that can be laid to rest by a line.
With Elvis in the ground his death is still out of my reach. This isn’t, I know, just another rock & roll death; it isn’t any kind of rock & roll death, because it is the only rock & roll death that cannot he contained by the various metaphors rock & roll has itself creased. Nor can it be contained, as Steve Dunleavy, and as times I, try to contain it, by showbiz metaphors. The problem – and it may take us years to really understand this, years during which some of us will have to keep these tiles clean and the stacks in order, reminding others that Elvis was not influenced by Chuck Berry, but by Roy Brown, and soon – is that there is just too much there, and that all of it — the art, the boy, the man, the source in the South, his reward is Hollywood, the recognition and adulation all over the world far more than twenty years — is all mixed up together.
The problem is that Elvis did flat simply change musical history, though of course he did that. He changed history, pure and simple, and in doing so, he became history — he became part of it, attached to it, as those of us who were changed by him, or changed ourselves because of things we glimpsed in him, are not. And it must be added that to change history is to do something that cannot be exactly figured or pinned down; it is to create and to pursue a mystery. That Elvis did what he did – and we do not know precisely what he did, because “Milkcow Blues Boogie” and “Hound Dog” cannot be figured out, exactly – means that the world became something other than what it would have been had he not done what he did, and that half-circle of a sentence has to be understood at the limit of its ability to mean anything at all. Because of Elvis’ emergence, because of who he was and what he became, because of his career and what we made of it, the American past, from the Civil War to the civil-rights movement, from Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln, looks different than it would have without Elvis. Because of that event, its moment – the mid-Fifties – was convulsed, and started over. Because of that event, the future has possibilities that otherwise would have been foreclosed.
And you see, we all knew this. We knew it, I think, all the time. You can hear it in the music. Somehow, Elvis must have had a sense of it, too That is why, really, his death makes no sense, no matter if he died of an “irregular heartbeat,” an overdose, as a suicide, is an accident, or any other way. And this is what, I think, Dave meant when he said that Elvis had always been there, and hinted thus, at least for those of us who helped make Elvis’ event, Elvis would of necessity have to outlive it. As with the death of FDR for another generation, it is not simply a man’s death that makes no sense, and is in some crucial, terrible way not real when history is personified and the person behind that history dies, history itself is no longer real.
My wife and I talked about some of this down at the bar, while I watched the ice melt in my Jack Daniel’s. She mentioned that she had asked me to take Elvis’ “Long Black Limousine,” from the 1969 comeback album, for our trip; for some reason I had never gotten around to it. It is quite a song: the story of a country girl who goes off to make it in the city, sell her soul, and come home, as she promised, riding in a fancy car — a hearse. Elvis never sang with more passion; he was bitter, and of what other recording by Elvis Presley can you say that? Of course, Elvis was no fool; he knew the song was about him, the country boy lost to the city if there ever was one, but he sang as if he liked that and loathed it all at once. He contained multitudes. His singing cut through the contradictions, blew them up. William Carlos Williams might say thus “the pure products of America go crazy,” but you might also say that the crazy products of America are pure, or something like that. When the stakes are as high as they always were in Elvis’ case, the neat phrase is not to be trusted; always it will obscure more than it will reveal. So we talked about “Long Black Limousine” and about the only Elvis music we did have along, an outtake of “Blue Moon of Kentucky,” from Elvis’ very first sessions in July of 1954, with studio dialogue bouncing back and forth between a nineteen-year-old Elvis, his accompanists Scotty Moose and Bill Black, and producer Sam Phillips. They were jammin’ like crazy, they said. And they were.
We sat for a while longer, and I ordered another Jack Daniel’s. My wife explained the rationale behind the drink to the bartender, who seemed amused. There was, he said, much more appropriate drinks. We asked what. “Why, a Blue Hawaii, of course,” he said. “You know, the movie?” That was two nights ago, but I still haven’t been able to bring myself to try one.
Elvis’ fans surrendered to him instinctively, willing to take what he gave (no master how silly), always confident that he could possess them completely any time he chose. Their faith, coupled with the complacency of his advisers, was both his glory and a plague. For if he was so great an artist in an environment where his mere presence was enough to incite riotous devotion, what might he have become in an atmosphere where creative challenge was fostered, risk encouraged, banality derided?
There is no denying that the final few years were depressing and humiliating — especially since their mediocrity followed the great moments of redemption, the 1968 TV show and the string of vital hits that surrounded it. “If I Can Dream,” “Kentucky Rain,” “The Wonder of You” and “Suspicious Minds” were among the greatest records he ever made. As depressing as the musical backsliding — perhaps more so — was the physical deterioration. From a lithe, athletic and infinitely sexual creature, Elvis became the antithesis of our dreams.
Still, many of us turned to each new record with expectations that must confound that who missed even the final glimmerings of his majesty. Why did we bother?
Because Elvis was unique. He had it all Every element of the rock & roll dream was his — pink Cadillacs, beautiful women, untold wealth, true genius and inspiration — and that was a claim no one else could ever make. A few others might have had some hope of it, most notably Chuck Berry. Berry united his own set of opposites: black and white, adult and teenage, verbal and nonverbal. But Berry was also black, and though he, too, blazed a tough and glorious path, his race denied him the full honor due his genius.
In a way, though, it was Berry’s story, because of songs like “Johnny B. Goode” and “Promised Land,” even though those songs came to stand as prophecies of Elvis, and finally as epitaphs for him. (It is especially ironic that those two songs were among the finest recordings of Elvis’ final years.( “Johnny B. Goode” was a story Elvis, and Elvis alone, lived out to the hilt. “Promised Land” must have seemed a plain fact to him — at least some of the time.
Perhaps I make too much of Elvis Presley — he was, after all, not a saint or a guru. But if any individual of our time can be said to have changed the world, Elvis Presley is the one. In his wake more than music is different. Nothing and no one looks or sounds the same. His music was the most liberating event of our era because it taught us new possibilities of feeling and perception, new modes of action and appearance, and because it reminded us not only of his greatness but of our own potential. If those things were not already so well integrated into our lives that they have become commonplace, it would be simpler to explain how astonishing a feat Elvis Presley’s advent really was.
Of course, it is unquestionable that there would have been rock & roll music without Elvis Presley. But oh it’s just as unquestionable that the kind of rock & roll we have — a matter of dreams and visions, not just facts and figures or even songs and singers — was shaped by him in the most fundamental ways.
His life must have been brutally lonely, for Elvis went it alone, took the biggest chance of all. One reason the Beatles did better, or at least lasted longer at their peak, was that they had learned from his mistakes and successes. Elvis had no such map to guide him, so he had to invent himself, over and over, come up with new terms for dealing with each situation. In the process, he invented us, whether or not we all know it. We are a hero-worshiping, thrill-crazy mob, I suppose, but at any best one that’s tuned into the heart of things — open, honest, unpretentious. Which is to say that he made us in his image.
Elvis was the King of rock & roll because he was the embodiment of its sins and virtues: grand and vulgar, rude and eloquent, powerful and frustrated, absurdly simple and awesomely complex. He was the King, I mean, in our hearts, which is the place where the music really comes to life. And just as rock & roll will stand as long as our hearts beat, he will always be our King: forever, irreplaceable, corrupt and incorruptible, beautiful and horrible, imprisoned and liberated. And finally, rockin’ and free, free at last.
Greil Marcus
Elvis Presley – “Heartbreak Hotel” (TV – 1956)
Elvis on TV back in 1956 – not sure what show this is from (it might be The Ed Sullivan Show…?)
Elvis Presley – “Polk Salad Annie” (Live – 1970)
Elvis performing this classic by the swamp rock king Tony Joe White. Taken from the 1970 concert film Elvis: That’s the Way It Is.